What the Chuck? – It’s only a trick play if it works Posted on October 20, 2015 by terrymeiners Posted in Uncategorized The Indianapolis Colts needed a boost to catch up with the New England Patriots. Colts coach Chuck Pagano called for a fake punt. It was, uh, fake alright. Colts fans, football fans, and even casual observers were flummoxed. The University of Maine tweeted an example of how a similar play helped them win an overtime game in 2011.